If you’re looking to set up a home gym, one of the things you’ll need to do is decide which area of the house you want to turn into your workout space.

The two most common options are the garage and the basement. In this post, we’ll explore the pros and cons of garage vs basement gym, so that you can make an informed decision about which one is right for you.

So let’s get started!

Benefits of a Basement Gym

The basements of most houses are underutilized so turning that unused space into a home gym is surely a good idea. Below are some of the major pros of a home basement gym:

1. Better Climate Control

No matter how hot or cold it is outside, the temperature of your basement gym will remain at a comfortable level. Unlike garage gyms, where the outside temperature can affect the workout space, your basement gym will be a consistent environment for you to work out in.

One of the main garage gym turn-offs for many people is to have to work out in sweltering heat or bone-chilling cold. With a basement gym, you’ll always be able to enjoy a nice and cozy workout environment.

2. Ease of Maintenance

Cleaning and maintaining a garage gym can be difficult, as it is an outdoor space and therefore exposed to dirt, dust, grime, and other unwanted buildups. You’ll need to clean all the equipment and the space on a regular basis in order to keep it in top condition. Otherwise, your garage gym will turn into a breeding ground for mold, bacteria, and other harmful elements.

By contrast, maintaining a basement gym is much easier. Since it’s an indoor space, you won’t have to deal with the elements and can get away with not cleaning the gym after every workout. However, you should still make a habit of cleaning and sanitizing your equipment to extend its lifespan.

3. Family-Friendly Space

If you have kids or other family members who want to be a part of your workout routine, a garage gym can pose some challenges. Garages are often not the safest areas of the home, as they’re easily accessible to anyone who can open the garage door. Plus, it won’t be a good idea to bring your kids and pets out to the garage when it’s extremely hot or cold outside.

On the other hand, basement gyms are more family-friendly and secure. Since they’re indoors, your home gym will be a safe and private space for you to enjoy a workout with family members, whether they’re joining in on the fun or simply tagging along for moral support.

4. More Privacy

Finally, some people just want to work out in peace and quiet. If this sounds like you, then a garage gym may not be the right choice. Since a garage is a more open and exposed space, you may find yourself constantly getting distracted by noises and other disturbances from the outside.

By contrast, basements are naturally quieter and more secluded, making them prime locations for a home gym that’s away from the hustle and bustle.

Drawbacks of a Basement Gym

While there are many benefits to having a basement gym, it’s important to consider the downsides as well. Here are some of the cons of this type of home gym setup:

1. Less Ventilation

One of the biggest drawbacks of basements is that they tend to have less consistent airflow and ventilation than garage gyms or other indoor spaces. This means that your basement gym will likely have higher levels of humidity, which can increase the risk of mold and mildew buildups.

Additionally, the humidity and moisture can lead to some of your gym equipment to rust.

And finally, the smell can become unbearable if you don’t keep a dehumidifier in the basement gym.

2. Low Clearance

Most of the basements have lower ceilings than other parts of the house. This generally means that overhead exercises like the military presses and Olympic lifts are pretty much out of the question.

Additionally, some of the squat racks and other machines may be too tall for your basement which basically limits the type of equipment you can keep and the type of exercises you can do in your basement gym.

3. Less Natural Light

Basements generally get little to no natural light which makes them dark and depressing. This isn’t an ideal environment to work out in for most people.

You’ll need to spend extra money on getting some extra lights and painting your basement with bright colors to make the space vibrant and energizing.

Be sure to also check out our post on the best lighting for home gyms.

4. Difficult to Setup

Transporting all of your gym equipment down the narrow stairs of basements can be a nightmare. Not only it is difficult to move the heavy equipment down there, but you also run the risk of injuring yourself or damaging the equipment.

You might even need to disassemble some of your exercise equipment before taking it downstairs and then re-assemble it in your basement. So this hectic process will require a lot of your time and maybe a whole weekend.

Now that we’ve looked at some of the major pros and cons of converting your basement into a gym, let’s take a look at how a gym in your garage compares.

Benefits of a Garage Gym:

Turning a garage into a gym is the preferred choice for most home gym enthusiasts and below are some of the reasons why:

1. Better Ventilation

Since garage gyms are located at ground level, they tend to have better ventilation and airflow. Having higher ceilings also helps in making the airflow better.

This means that you’ll get fresh air in your gym space and won’t be breathing in the residual moisture and odor from your workout. Additionally, good airflow will protect your gym equipment from bad odors, mold, and rust.

After all, who wants to work out in a suffocating and smelly space?

2. More Natural Light

Natural sunlight is a great energy booster. Research has shown that natural lighting and even artificial lighting that can mimic natural light can improve your mood and energy.

This means that you’ll feel more motivated and energized to work out and get one step closer to achieving your fitness goals.

However, you’ll still need some artificial lighting in your garage if you usually work out in the evening or really early in the morning.

3. Generally More Spacious

Home garages generally have more open space than basements which means that you’ll have a lot of room to move around and set up your gym equipment the way you want.

Working out in an open space makes your workouts more refreshing and you feel less suffocated no matter how hot the temperature is.

You can also use garage organization systems like garage shelving to organize your space and make it look neat and tidy.

4. Gives You More Flexibility

Since you have more open space and you can also open your garage door, garage gyms give you a lot of flexibility in terms of the type of exercises you can do.

If it is too hot and humid inside the garage, you can always move some of your equipment outside and get a nice workout in the open air.

Plus, you also get the flexibility to do exercises like walking lunges, agility drills, and even running.

So if you’re looking for a more versatile and functional gym space that gives you plenty of flexibility, garage gyms are the way to go.

Drawbacks of a Garage Gym

Although garage gyms are more popular than basement gyms but they also have some drawbacks that you need to consider before making a decision.

1. More Noise Pollution

Working out in your garage can be noisier for the neighbors than working out in the basement.

Since garage gyms are located outside the house, any loud music or weights dropping on the floor can be easily heard by your neighbors and even people on the street.

This can be particularly annoying for other people if you work out at odd hours like late at night or really early in the morning.

So if own a garage gym, you’ll need to take the noise factor into consideration when working out.

2. Requires Regular Cleaning

Dirt and debris can easily enter your garage gym through the garage door and windows.

This means that you’ll have to clean and sweep your garage regularly to keep it looking neat and tidy.

This isn’t necessarily a drawback, but you’ll need to spend a few extra minutes every day and then every week to make sure that all of your gym equipment along with the floor is clean and free of any dust or grime.

Be sure to check out our post on how to keep a garage gym clean.

3. Little to No Insulation

Garages generally have little to no insulation which means that it might get too hot during summer and too cold in winter.

So you’ll need to spend some extra money on the insulation of your garage gym to ensure that it remains comfortable throughout the year.

Additionally, you’ll also need to weather-strip the windows and door of your garage so that you can maintain a nice temperature inside the garage.

4. Loss of Parking Space

If you own a one-car garage, it’s likely that you’ll have to park your car on the street.

This means that your car will be exposed to the elements and therefore will require regular cleaning to maintain its appearance.

Plus, chores like washing your car or changing the oil might also become a little more difficult when you don’t have garage access.

Is it Better to Have a Gym in the Garage or Basement?

Based on the pros and cons we’ve mentioned above for both options, we suggest that turning your garage into a home gym rather than your basement is a better decision.

You’ll have more space and flexibility in terms of the types of exercises you can do, and you’ll have better ventilation and natural lighting as compared to your basement.

Having said that, the basement gym isn’t a bad option either. It really depends on your personal preferences and which factors are more important to you.

You can refer to the below table to see a quick comparison of garage and basement gyms:

Garage Gym and Basement Gym Comparison

Is Garage Too Hot for Gym?

If you live in a hot and humid climate, there’s a chance that your garage might be too hot to be used as a gym.

However, you can always take some steps to bring the temperature down to a comfortable level. Those steps include installing a fan or an AC in your garage, opening the windows and doors of your garage for better insulation, etc.

You can also check out our 15 Tips to keep your garage gym cool in summer.

Final Thoughts

Turning an area of your home into a gym is surely a great way to commit to your fitness goals. We hope that the information in this post about garage vs basement gym will help you understand which option is better for you.

Do you have any other questions or thoughts on this matter? Let us know in the comments section below!

Write A Comment